Skip to main content

Extended Warranties: Prudent Purchase or a Waste of Money?

Published September 27, 2019

3 minute read

Joshua Williams

By Joshua Williams

WalletPop has broken a story about a suit being leveled against U.S. Fidelis and Credexx regarding allegedly abusive advertising methods resulting in consumers purchasing worthless extended warranties. Several states are suing both companies. They say the two companies tricked consumers into purchasing extended warranties — through alarmist voicemails and postcards announcing the imminent termination of coverage — that often did not cover what they claimed to.

This gets into the case of extended warranties, which are often borderline rackets.

What is a Warranty?

Devices that come with warranties do so because if there was an error in construction, the device will fail early. No manufacturing process is perfect and some errors are inevitable. But the whole warranty system is set to correct these mistakes.

The end of the standard warranty is set at the end of the period where manufacturing errors are likely to occur, whether it be one year, two years, or something else. The idea is that if the device makes it past that date without failure, then it was constructed correctly and will continue to work for the expected life of the device.

The company offers warranties because these early failures are easier to replace free of charge than initiating a widespread recall or suffering a huge drop in public perception.

What is an Extended Warranty?

Extended warranties cover the device in the period after the standard warranty ends. And as I said, if the device has made it through the life of the standard warranty without failure, it is very likely to last through its expected life. So extended warranties cover the period of time when failures are highly unlikely to occur and they always run out before the expected life of the device.

For example, a new computer usually comes with a one year warranty. If any failure occurs in this time, such as a broken power supply or cooling fan, then the computer was likely manufactured incorrectly. If no error occurs, the computer is almost guaranteed to last the expected life a computer; say between four and six years. So if you buy an extended warranty for another two years, you’re covering the time when the computer would be working fine. Inevitably, some failures do occur during this time, however as I’ve been saying, they are highly unlikely.

Buyer Beware

These extended warranties exist, therefore, to try to trick consumers out of more money. They feed on the fear of a failure, which is highly unlikely to occur.

The company sets the price of the standard warranty based on what it expects to payout. The manufacturer will have data on how often errors occur and will use this. The price of the warranty is usually absorbed into the normal price. Companies want to keep this low, so they can sell more. However, extended warranties cost the buyer significantly more than the company expects to pay.

They are still a legal service to offer. Unless, of course, they are abusively advertised or don’t actually follow through on repair services, as U.S. Fidelis and Credexx’s services are alleged to.

Extended Warranty Label

Aquir / Shutterstock

Joshua Williams


Joshua is a freelance writer with years of experience blogging about business and finance, and a whole host of other things too. When he's not writing, he enjoys camping with his dog, a golden retriever named Oakley.

Explore Financial Advice

See All In Financial Advice

More from WalletGenius

Young couple worried about finances Save Money

How To Tell If Your Retirement Is In Jeopardy

One of the most common financial concerns for adults these days is retirement. It comes up over and over again. For anyone concerned about money, retirement is a very big problem to confront. Current (and future) generations of working-aged Americans aren’t exactly fairing well, when it comes to retirement savings. Some studies have shown that […]

Read More about Post Title

7 minute read

Young woman worried about student loans Perkins loans Student Loans

Perkins Loans: Everything You Need To Know

A Perkins Loan was a federal program that provided low-interest loans to college students who demonstrated exceptional financial need. The program, which operated as the “Perkins Loan Program,” no longer exists. It was discontinued on September 30, 2017. The final disbursements were permitted through June 30, 2018. Although the program has been discontinued, many current […]

Read More about Post Title

5 minute read

Capital budgeting paperwork Budgeting

Capital Budgeting: A Complete Guide

Capital budgeting is a business term used to describe the process of determining how to best use the capital the company has on hand. Should they expand? Should they reinvest in a new factory to increase capacity? Is it profitable to acquire another business for expansion? In other words, capital budgeting is the process of […]

Read More about Post Title

7 minute read

Woman checking her credit score Credit

What You Need to Know About Free Credit Scores

You probably know that your credit score is an important aspect of your finances. Your credit score goes beyond just helping you get a loan with a good interest rate. It can also influence your insurance rates and even impact what happens when you sign up for internet or a cell phone plan. Knowing your […]

Read More about Post Title

7 minute read


EBITDA: What Is It and How Is It Calculated?

It might look like it, but EBITDA is not actually an alien word. It is an acronym that stands for “earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization.” As you may have guessed by now, it’s a metric used in the business world. A company’s EBITDA can help you better understand their ability to generate cash […]

Read More about Post Title

6 minute read

Trusted provider of accurate rates & financial information