Skip to main content

Payroll Service Providers That Won’t Break the Bank for Your Small Business

4 minute read

Devon Taylor

By Devon Taylor

Growing your small business is exciting! But that excitement comes with certain growing pains. Once you have more than a handful of employees, you’re likely going to want to digitize and automate your payroll. After all, do you want to spend your days doing tedious payroll tasks or focus your efforts on providing the best product or services you can? Luckily, there are numerous online payroll services to make the job easy and seamless. Searching online for HR and payroll software is a great place to start.

There are at least a dozen of these services that remain popular choices. The right one for you depends on a few things:

Some are fairly simple, handling payroll deposits and not much else. Others can also handle HR tasks like recording sick days, distributing benefits, booking vacation time, along with dolling out tax documents. Whatever your business needs, an online search for the best payroll service providers is how to start researching. Or keep reading for our take on the most popular options.

OnPay

Price: $36 per month, plus $4 per employee

OnPay, quite simply, is one of the best and most-popular payroll services available right now. For a relatively small cost, it offers a straightforward and easy to use all-in-one service suite. You’ll have access to payroll for both W-2 and 1099 workers, plus automatic tax payments and filings. There’s also a handy employee self-service portal that your workers can use to download documents and manage PTO.

OnPay also offers benefits management solutions. That means you can administer health insurance or retirement plans without needing another company. The only real downside of OnPay is that there’s no free-trial to test it out. It also doesn’t have built-in accounting tools, but it does integrate well with third-party ones like QuickBooks, Xero, and When I Work.

Gusto

Price: $39 per month, plus $6 per employee

Gusto was designed specifically for start-ups and small businesses. If you run a medium- to large-sized company, it may not work quite as well. The $6 per employee can add up fast for companies with hundreds of workers.

With that being said, Gusto has plenty of attractive options. Gusto allows payments for both employees and independent contractors. It even has a lower-cost “contractor only” plan, if your company technically doesn’t have its own employees. It can also manage health care, retirement plans, and even an employee wellness portal.

Gusto has a couple very modern features that are somewhat unique, such as an automated donation tool for employees to give to charity and an online wallet that lets workers better control their money. Unfortunately, Gusto only works for companies and workers located entirely in the United States.

ADP Run

Price: $59+ per month, depending on the size and needs of the company

ADP is one of the largest payroll service providers in the industry. It has its own small business offshoot called ADP Run, which is a great service for any burgeoning entrepreneur. It has the added advantage of being able to grow with your business, even if your small outfit suddenly finds itself with hundreds of employees around the country.

ADP includes a solid HR platform alongside its payroll services. That means you can have it handle things like:

While ADP Run is technically designed for companies with less than 50 employees, you can easily transition to ADP Enterprise if you grow beyond that. The only downside is that ADP charges extra fees for certain things, like contractor payments or benefits administration.

Paychex Flex

Price: $39+ per month, depending on company size and needs

Like ADP Run, Paychex Flex is designed for small businesses with less than 50 employees. On the plus side, it’s cheaper than ADP Run and offers most of the same services.

Flex is an easy-to-use online platform for paying both full employees and contractors. Unfortunately, it lacks a system to administer benefits. There’s also an extra fee for filing payroll tax and filing W-2 and 1099 forms.

The good news is that if you like Paychex Flex and wish it had more features, you can add other Paychex services to meet those needs. So this  payroll service can grow alongside your business.

Justworks

Price: $49 per month (up to 25 employees)

If your small business caters to a team of remote workers, Justworks might be the best payroll solution for you.

Justworks is technically a professional employee organization. That is an employer of record for your workers. Basically, it handles HR and payroll on your behalf. That makes it slightly different from the other options in this article.

Since Justworks offers a co-employment arrangement, they actually absorb some of the legal liability that you would normally have to shoulder as a sole employer. Most other payroll software or services don’t offer this. As a trade off, you give Justworks a bit more control over things like employee handbooks and workplace policies.

While it might seem a bit expensive at first, keep in mind that you probably don’t need to hire a dedicated HR employee or benefits administration person. So it could actually save you money in the long run.

Justworks is great if you have complex or international hiring practices. On the other hand, you have to be comfortable giving up control of your HR policies.

TarikVision / Shutterstock

Devon Taylor

Managing Editor

Devon is an experienced writer and a father of three young children. He's simultaneously trying to build college funds and plan for an eventual retirement. He's been in online publishing since 2013 and has a degree from the University of Guelph. In his free time, he loves fanatically following the Blue Jays and Toronto FC, camping with his family, and playing video games.

Explore

Military Salaries, Retirement, and What to Expect Make Money

Military Salaries, Retirement, and What to Expect

Have you ever wondered what the paycheck and salary structure of military personnel looks like? Similar to their job description, their salary and payment structure differs greatly from that of civilians. How one receives a paycheck as a U.S. troop is more complicated than getting paid for working your regular nine-to-five job. The U.S. military […]

Read More about Military Salaries, Retirement, and What to Expect

5 minute read

New Year’s Resolutions 2022: Make More Money Make Money

New Year’s Resolutions 2022: Make More Money

One of the cornerstones of the frugal lifestyle is spending less. However, while you are making your New Year’s Resolutions for 2022, don’t stop at spending less or cutting costs. Consider this as an additional resolution: Make more money. Don’t get me wrong. You absolutely want to focus on reducing your expenses (or at least […]

Read More about New Year’s Resolutions 2022: Make More Money

7 minute read

Jobs For Those Needing a Better Work Life Balance work life balance Make Money

Jobs For Those Needing a Better Work Life Balance

We hear a lot about the importance of a work life balance. After all, what’s the point of earning that money if we spend all our waking hours working, never getting time to enjoy life? Unfortunately, the invention of laptops and smartphones means that many employees find themselves answering emails or phone calls at all […]

Read More about Jobs For Those Needing a Better Work Life Balance

7 minute read

The Best Seasonal Jobs That Can Make You Extra Money Make Money

The Best Seasonal Jobs That Can Make You Extra Money

Whether you’re a college student looking to earn a little extra money or an older citizen simply trying to top your budget, there are plenty of seasonal employment opportunities. Some jobs are constantly rolling in and out of popularity, as the months roll by. Even thought the word “seasonal” implies the jobs are only temporary, […]

Read More about The Best Seasonal Jobs That Can Make You Extra Money

8 minute read

The Best Reasons to Start a Side Business in 2021 Make Money

The Best Reasons to Start a Side Business in 2021

Entrepreneurship isn’t always the easiest path to take. Many people start and fail at their businesses, year in and year out. After all, it’s well known that most businesses fail. In fact, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reports that approximately one-fifth of businesses fail after the first two years. Around 65% fail within […]

Read More about The Best Reasons to Start a Side Business in 2021

4 minute read

See all in Make Money