Skip to main content

Should You Pay Up Front or Over Time? How to Handle a Large Bill

Published May 27, 2020

6 minute read

Rebecca Henderson

By Rebecca Henderson

What can put you both in the red and the black, financially speaking? Bills.

Yes, we mean those greenbacks you work for to afford things like housing, utilities, and groceries. But those same amenities cost you throughout the month. Dollar bills increase our financial wealth, while service bills decrease it.

It’s a fact of life. More importantly though, handling bills correctly — and we’re still talking both types — is crucial to financial success. Managing your money requires a learning curve, for sure. Luckily, we’re here to help you with one of the big questions you’ll face someday. Should you pay a large bill up front, in full? Or over time, in installments?

Dealing with Debt Requires a Strategy

There’s no concrete answer to this question. It will depend entirely on your own financial situation. What works for one person may not be wise for another. The best way to go about deciding how you should tackle debt is to first consider your present finances. Take a quick inventory of where you’re at with income, savings, and expenses — excluding the large bill before you.

Another way to look at things is to consider what benefits you’ll enjoy from each method. How can paying up-front or over time contribute to your financial success, both now and in the long-run? With that also comes a focus on the drawbacks of either path. Really, the balance comes in choosing a plan that will help you the most, while hurting you the least.

Paying Up-Front: One and Done

On paper, paying your debts in-full and up-front leads to the best financial outcome. You stamp out debt as soon as it appears and still manage to keep afloat. However, that’s simply not possible for many folks, and especially in these times. When your fridge dies suddenly or a surprise car repair bill hits, not everyone has the luxury of paying instantly.

Still, being able to pay your large debt entirely can sound like an achievement. You won’t be sacrificing money to interest charges and the amount you are billed is the exact amount you’ll be charged. The stress of having a monthly payment will be removed from your shoulders. Your future money will be freed up to do with as you please.

All this comes with the caveat that you have the full amount to pay the large bill before you. In some cases, that’s not even possible. If you can’t pay in full because you simply don’t have the cash, your choice has been made for you. It’s best to choose a monthly payment method instead.

Maybe your situation is somewhere between those two extremes. You could pay that large bill up front, but it should severely tighten your finances for a few months. We’re talking peanuts and breadcrumbs for every meal — no minor setback. That creates a whole new stress. With barely any savings to your name, the choice is clear. Little by little beats one large chunk, at least in your case.

Monthly Installments: Slow and Steady Pays the Debt

So why would it be better to pay monthly?

For starters, even if you were to get a loan to pay off the bill amount in full, you’d still have that monthly loan payment to contend with. Ideally, you’d choose a loan with lower interest charges than the bill you received. But what if that wasn’t possible? You might end up paying more. Plus you’ll have to deal with managing the loan on top of it all.

The best way to categorize payments on a large bill is to think of them as a recurring monthly bill, like your utilities. For example, you (should) budget for things like housing, food, and utilities each month. You might have a car payment on top of that, in addition to gym memberships, media subscriptions, and anything else you pay monthly for. If you can think of the bill payment as just another monthly service, it’s a much easier amount to tackle.

Benefits to paying through installments occur on your credit report as well. Forbes reports that your payment history makes up 35% percent of your credit score. It’s not about whether or not you can afford to pay large debts, but whether you can manage them over time and in a financially responsible manner. Each on-time payment contributes to the good payment history you build each month.

Cold Hard Cash: Snowball and Avalanche Methods

Financial experts have even created nicknames for the strategies you can implement to pay off large debts that come with a monthly payment. The first is called the snowball method. It begins small but with large rewards. Rank your debts from smallest to largest. Commit the minimum balance to each, while using as much remaining income to pay off the smallest debt first. When that smallest debt is eliminated, move on to the next smallest. Continue this method until each of your debts is paid off.

In contrast, the avalanche method works to pay off the debt with the highest interest rate first. It may not work as quickly as the snowball method, but you are controlling the interest you’ll be charged by facing it directly. If you do the math, you probably save money in the long run with the avalanche method.

Depending on your financial situation and debts in total, sometimes a combination of these methods works the best. Small debts can be paid off quickly while those with the highest interest rate become a priority. It’s all in how you manage your finances.

Focus on Your Finances

If you’re still wondering what the best path for you is, take a look at the following questions. As you answer them, a choice should make itself clear.

The important thing to remember is that both scenarios keep your credit intact, as long as you make your monthly payments. Much like credit cards, mortgage payments, and car loans, long-term payments boost your credibility with debtors. Paying debts off in full as you get them comes with a certain financial confidence as well. As long as you’ve got a plan in place, financial stability and success are just a matter of time.

Invest in Your Financial Success

If you’d like to learn more about debt and how to approach it, check out this article on debt relief vs. debt consolidation. You can find out more about budgeting here. We always encourage savvy readers to remember these common myths about credit scores. Your financial success is attainable, and we are here to support you. Stay tuned for tips, guides, and plenty more to put you on the path to financial freedom.

The Last Word

No one likes being hit with a large, unexpected bill. Many Americans simply whip out the credit card and think “I’ll worry about this later.” After all, your family can’t live without a working furnace in the middle of winter. Or you absolutely need a working vehicle to get your job every day. So you bite the bullet, and pay the bill — one way or another.

The factor you really need to consider is “what is the true cost of my decision?” For example, paying in installments might ease your monthly budget but dramatically jack up the cost of your bill. Predatory interest rates could mean your $3,000 medical bill ends up costing you over $5,000 by the time you make 24 monthly payments.

On the other hand, if paying that $3,000 up front means your family is living off ramen noodles for the next six months, that’s not great either. While your specific financial situation will always help guide you towards one answer or the other, make sure you consider all the angles the next time you’re hit with an unexpected large bill.

Woman Shocked by Large Bill

Shutterstock

Rebecca Henderson

Freelance Writer

Rebecca Henderson has a Master's in German and a Bachelor's in Creative Writing. She alternates her time between writing and working on a variety of motorized projects. Most recently, she and her boyfriend have been building a custom drift trike. Rebecca believes that language, love, and a life worth living are only the first ingredients to happiness.

Explore Budgeting

Budgeting

How To Plan Your 2021 Christmas Budget

As much as I love gift-giving and the holiday season in general, I often find that it sneaks up on me. If you’re anything like me, you often find yourself in mid-December scrambling to get presents bought, wrapped, and even mailed. That last minute scramble often means paying more for gifts than you intended, since […]

Read More about Post Title

7 minute read

Capital budgeting paperwork Budgeting

Capital Budgeting: A Complete Guide

Capital budgeting is a business term used to describe the process of determining how to best use the capital the company has on hand. Should they expand? Should they reinvest in a new factory to increase capacity? Is it profitable to acquire another business for expansion? In other words, capital budgeting is the process of […]

Read More about Post Title

7 minute read

Budgeting

EBITDA: What Is It and How Is It Calculated?

It might look like it, but EBITDA is not actually an alien word. It is an acronym that stands for “earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization.” As you may have guessed by now, it’s a metric used in the business world. A company’s EBITDA can help you better understand their ability to generate cash […]

Read More about Post Title

6 minute read

Budgeting

Effective Ways To Practice Self-Care on a Budget

Self-care is defined by the World Health Organization as “the ability of individuals, families and communities to promote health with or without the support of a healthcare provider.” More broadly, self-care is described as an individual nurturing their spiritual, emotional, and physical health. It’s an important part of keeping your mental health in a healthy […]

Read More about Post Title

7 minute read

See All In Budgeting

More from WalletGenius

Budgeting

How To Plan Your 2021 Christmas Budget

As much as I love gift-giving and the holiday season in general, I often find that it sneaks up on me. If you’re anything like me, you often find yourself in mid-December scrambling to get presents bought, wrapped, and even mailed. That last minute scramble often means paying more for gifts than you intended, since […]

Read More about Post Title

7 minute read

Financial Advice

How To Avoid Paying These Hidden Fees

One of my good friends is a financial planner. He recently told me something very interesting about hidden fees. He basically said that his income comes from the fees that he charges his clients. They are typically based on a percentage of the client’s assets. That means that every quarter (or annually), those fees are […]

Read More about Post Title

8 minute read

Financial Advice

How Do You Justify Your Debt?

Most of us are well aware how debt works. We know we shouldn’t buy things that we can’t afford. Instead, we know we’re supposed to save up for major purchases. It’s just smart financial sense to not make a bunch of purchases that drive up your debt. However, when it all comes right down to […]

Read More about Post Title

8 minute read

Woman stressed from overworking Financial Advice

Are You Actually Working Too Much?

Our society just idolizes “more” for some reason. We often talk about the mentality of “keeping up with the Joneses” in the context of material possessions often. However, I’ve noticed lately that people are just as impressed with those who seem to be “doing” more — and no, not doing more at work. We also […]

Read More about Post Title

8 minute read

Woman working on her finances Financial Advice

Easy Ways to Simplify Your Finances

“Life is really simple, but we insist on making it complicated.” – Confucius Personal finance is surprisingly simple. Live below your means. Invest for the long term. Keep at it. Prosper. Yet, we instinctively want to complicate the process because we can’t trust that something so important can be so simple. I mean, how can […]

Read More about Post Title

7 minute read

Flipping Houses Home Ownership

How to Start Flipping Houses (And Actually Make Money)

House-flipping is often portrayed as a foolproof path to quick riches. While this inaccuracy can create unrealistic expectations, flipping houses can definitely be profitable if you do it right. And that’s the trick: the people most successful at flipping houses are generally the most experienced. That said, they all started somewhere. There’s nothing like completing […]

Read More about Post Title

6 minute read

TSP Loans Loans

TSP Loan: Everything You Need To Know

TSP loans are specialized loans designed for employees of the United States federal government. They offer federal employees access to a unique loan class that uses their retirement plans to finance their borrowing needs. Financial advisors often liken them to the 401(k) loans available to members of the general public. Yet, TSP loans differ from […]

Read More about Post Title

5 minute read

Trusted provider of accurate rates & financial information